From the inventor
Why this work began
From the inventor
Today we began with a question that seemed simple. How can two people who know each other intimately understand the same moment so differently? As inventors, we don't begin by assuming that the answer is a product. We begin by trying to define the problem. I wanted to put the reader inside an ordinary relationship, not tell them what to think about it. So I wrote a story. Then we asked a second question: if that moment could be interrupted before anyone was harmed, what would have to be possible? This document is where that investigation begins.
We are a team of inventors. We identify problems, try to understand them and ask whether something could be designed to prevent them.
This document begins with a fictional story, not a report of a real incident. It is how we have chosen to define the problem we are investigating. We invite you to read it and make your own judgments. We will not tell you what to think about the couple, their relationship or the narrator.
After the story we explain the problem, replay the same afternoon with a proposed intervention, and return to the inventors' voice to explain what we want to investigate. This is a proposal for discussion, not an announcement of a finished invention.
The original story / Version 2
I Raped Her
A fictional narrative by Simon Macbeth
Friday, 20 November 2026.
I'm sat at home on the sofa, scrolling through Facebook. No real plans for the day.
She's upstairs. Doing whatever she's doing.
It doesn't matter what either of us is doing. We're happy just to exist together. Doing our own things.
We've been together five years.
And Jesus Christ, I love that woman.
I don't just love her. She's everything.
I've had girlfriends before her. A lot of girlfriends. A lot of sex. I never thought I could possibly be in a relationship with one single woman and for that person to be enough.
But she's not just enough.
She's everything.
I think about her. Talk about her, like I'm doing now. And I struggle to stop tears from rolling down my cheeks.
Every morning for five years is like waking up on Christmas morning as an eight-year-old boy. Realising Santa Claus has brought everything you were hoping and dreaming for.
And then there's this extra present. This enormous present. Something you did want. Something you dreamed about. But in your young mind you didn't even realise it was possible Santa Claus could bring something just so unimaginably amazing.
How is it possible that I've got all this?
It's not a dream come true. It's beyond a dream come true.
You just cannot compute it. You just cannot possibly understand this sort of connection nor our love.
And that's how I feel every morning. Every single morning. Since before we even met in person.
I trust her. Completely. I trust that I know her. That we understand each other. I trust that when she wants something, I know what she wants.
I could spend an eternity trying to explain exactly what she means to me. Still, that wouldn't be enough time.
There's nothing without her. Nothing matters. It's like now I'm part of this universe, with everything in it that exists. But if she's not part of that universe, then - POP!
Just me in a void of dark nothingness. Floating across all space and time for eternity.
That's what she means to me.
But that's not why we're talking today.
So. Back to Friday.
I'm sat there on the sofa. Scrolling through Facebook.
She comes downstairs and sits beside me. On my left-hand side. Really close.
Her right arm rests on the back of the sofa. Her breasts are pressed into my arm.
I know what that mean. I know that look on her face.
I know what that means.
It's happened a thousand times before.
She places her left hand on my leg. Massages it a bit. Strokes it.
She's a tactile person. I understand every different type of way she touches me. What they mean. What she wants. This time it's not, 'Are you okay, love?'
It's more than that.
It's one of her ways of communicating that she wants sex.
God, she's so fucking beautiful!
The very first time I saw a photo of her, I thought she was the most beautiful woman I'd ever seen. A complete ten out of ten. I often try to think of a reason why she isn't a ten out of ten. Especially when she pisses me off.
I've failed to find even one.
And then I met her in person.
Fucking hell!
I'm the luckiest person in the world. Literally.
And there she is. Her breast against my arm. Her hand massaging my thigh. Now my inner thigh.
I'm instantly turned on.
Sex has always been important to us.
We get bored? Solution. Sex.
We have a fight? Sex.
We're drifting apart? Sex.
We don't spend enough time together? Sex.
She thinks it’s my turn to take the bin out? Sex.
It's not everything in our relationship. But it's important.
It's the foundation. The architecture of our relationship. The solution to so many of our problems. And we love that about our relationship.
We have this little game together.
I once said there's nothing she can do to scare me. So, in a playful way, she's always trying.
Two days ago, I got up in the morning, half asleep. Took my towel. Went into the bathroom for a shower.
She jumped out at me.
She'd been hiding in the shower. I didn't know she was there. But it didn't faze me. Didn't scare me at all.
She'd taken a shower twenty minutes earlier. It was still wet. And she had socks on.
She slipped.
Fell flat on her arse.
She didn't hurt herself, of course. We both laughed.
She tried to scare me and fell on her arse instead.
It's one of those memories I know I'll cherish. One of the memories I'll try to hold on to when I lose my whole universe.
Because it was special.
I do silly things to scare her all the time too.
I'd creep up behind her when she's washing up. Touch that sensitive bit on her side, between her rib cage and her bum. Just gently.
And softly say, 'Boo'.
She jumps. Calls me a twat. Or says, 'God, you're such an arsehole.'
And laughs.
But she loves it as much as I do. She tells me so often that she does. I know exactly how to scare her the way she loves. It's just one of those silly little things she often tells me.
She's amazing.
So there we are on the sofa.
She's massaging my leg. And I've completely ignored her. Haven't reacted at all.
I'm playing hard to get.
She knows that. She likes it. She's told me a million times how much that turns her on.
And in turn, it turns me on just as much.
This is why it works between us.
This is why sex solves everything. It always has.
It's the constant.
So, I decide to scare her.
A little surprise.
Just like we've done a thousand times before.
That was the worst decision I've ever made.
I did it because I love her. Because, from the bottom of my heart, I believe it's what she wants. What she needs.
Everything that's happened between us. All those experiences. All those memories. All those feelings over those five years.
I know her.
I love her.
I trust her.
And I trust that she wants me.
So I jump towards her.
I playfully push her down on the sofa. Hold her wrists.
I pull her knickers to one side.
I'm so hard. She's so wet.
I enter her.
Oh, we've always loved that feeling as I first enter her.
She's told me so many times how much she loves it. In turn I learned to love it too. It was us, our moment. Our love.
That feeling. That moment. That closeness. That bond. That connection.
Looking into each other's eyes.
We've both always known exactly what each other was thinking and feeling right then in that moment.
It's happened a million times before.
But this time it isn't there. It's different. I knew instantly our eyes met.
She doesn't have to tell me.
She doesn't have to say anything.
She looks terrified.
Terrified.
And that was the first time my heart ever broke.
That's the moment I realise nothing will ever be the same again.
Nothing could be.
You see, something happened before she came down and sat next to me that day.
She was chatting to her friends, scrolling through Facebook. TikTok. Somewhere. I don't know.
She'd seen a silly post. Something like, 'How quickly can you turn your man on?'
It was meant to be a joke. Something for her to laugh about with her friends.
I didn't know any of this.
Not until the police told me the next day.
I'd spent that night in a police station.
It was cold. Scary.
I've never felt so alone.
All I wanted was for her to be okay. To wrap my arms around her. To tell her I was sorry. That I fucked up…. That it wasn't her fault.
I am so fucking sorry!
She'd come downstairs to test me. It was supposed to be fun. A joke. Part of our amazing shared history of being playful, having fun and laughing.
She didn't want sex.
She came to test and tease me. To see how quickly she could turn me on. Then she could go back upstairs and report to her friends.
She wanted to giggle with the people she'd grown-up with. Those friends who she loved as much as we loved each other. She just wanted to giggle.
A few seconds. That's all it took.
It was a laugh. A joke.
She loved me just as much as I loved her.
Everything I've told you about what she means to me? She felt exactly the same about me.
She trusted me too.
And what was I doing while she was having a laugh and a joke with her friends?
I was sitting there.
Waiting for the woman I love more than anything in the universe.
Waiting for the moment that I raped her.
The question
What would need to change?
The story shows a devastating difference between a person's confidence and the other person's actual wishes. The man relies on familiarity, shared history and his interpretation of behaviour. None of those things, however meaningful to him, can substitute for establishing consent.
As inventors, we ask a practical question: could a communication system recognise an approaching moment of danger and interrupt it early enough to give both people an opportunity to understand what is happening?
We are not claiming to have built that system. We are describing the outcome we want to investigate. The following replay starts in the same place, using the same story, but branches at the moment when the man moves towards his partner.
The same afternoon / A hypothetical replay
A different outcome
Read the same beginning again
Friday, 20 November 2026.
I'm sat at home on the sofa, scrolling through Facebook. No real plans for the day.
She's upstairs. Doing whatever she's doing.
It doesn't matter what either of us is doing. We're happy just to exist together. Doing our own things.
We've been together five years.
And Jesus Christ, I love that woman.
I don't just love her. She's everything.
I've had girlfriends before her. A lot of girlfriends. A lot of sex. I never thought I could possibly be in a relationship with one single woman and for that person to be enough.
But she's not just enough.
She's everything.
I think about her. Talk about her, like I'm doing now. And I struggle to stop tears from rolling down my cheeks.
Every morning for five years is like waking up on Christmas morning as an eight-year-old boy. Realising Santa Claus has brought everything you were hoping and dreaming for.
And then there's this extra present. This enormous present. Something you did want. Something you dreamed about. But in your young mind you didn't even realise it was possible Santa Claus could bring something just so unimaginably amazing.
How is it possible that I've got all this?
It's not a dream come true. It's beyond a dream come true.
You just cannot compute it. You just cannot possibly understand this sort of connection nor our love.
And that's how I feel every morning. Every single morning. Since before we even met in person.
I trust her. Completely. I trust that I know her. That we understand each other. I trust that when she wants something, I know what she wants.
I could spend an eternity trying to explain exactly what she means to me. Still, that wouldn't be enough time.
There's nothing without her. Nothing matters. It's like now I'm part of this universe, with everything in it that exists. But if she's not part of that universe, then - POP!
Just me in a void of dark nothingness. Floating across all space and time for eternity.
That's what she means to me.
But that's not why we're talking today.
So. Back to Friday.
I'm sat there on the sofa. Scrolling through Facebook.
She comes downstairs and sits beside me. On my left-hand side. Really close.
Her right arm rests on the back of the sofa. Her breasts are pressed into my arm.
I know what that mean. I know that look on her face.
I know what that means.
It's happened a thousand times before.
She places her left hand on my leg. Massages it a bit. Strokes it.
She's a tactile person. I understand every different type of way she touches me. What they mean. What she wants. This time it's not, 'Are you okay, love?'
It's more than that.
It's one of her ways of communicating that she wants sex.
God, she's so fucking beautiful!
The very first time I saw a photo of her, I thought she was the most beautiful woman I'd ever seen. A complete ten out of ten. I often try to think of a reason why she isn't a ten out of ten. Especially when she pisses me off.
I've failed to find even one.
And then I met her in person.
Fucking hell!
I'm the luckiest person in the world. Literally.
And there she is. Her breast against my arm. Her hand massaging my thigh. Now my inner thigh.
I'm instantly turned on.
Sex has always been important to us.
We get bored? Solution. Sex.
We have a fight? Sex.
We're drifting apart? Sex.
We don't spend enough time together? Sex.
She thinks it’s my turn to take the bin out? Sex.
It's not everything in our relationship. But it's important.
It's the foundation. The architecture of our relationship. The solution to so many of our problems. And we love that about our relationship.
We have this little game together.
I once said there's nothing she can do to scare me. So, in a playful way, she's always trying.
Two days ago, I got up in the morning, half asleep. Took my towel. Went into the bathroom for a shower.
She jumped out at me.
She'd been hiding in the shower. I didn't know she was there. But it didn't faze me. Didn't scare me at all.
She'd taken a shower twenty minutes earlier. It was still wet. And she had socks on.
She slipped.
Fell flat on her arse.
She didn't hurt herself, of course. We both laughed.
She tried to scare me and fell on her arse instead.
It's one of those memories I know I'll cherish. One of the memories I'll try to hold on to when I lose my whole universe.
Because it was special.
I do silly things to scare her all the time too.
I'd creep up behind her when she's washing up. Touch that sensitive bit on her side, between her rib cage and her bum. Just gently.
And softly say, 'Boo'.
She jumps. Calls me a twat. Or says, 'God, you're such an arsehole.'
And laughs.
But she loves it as much as I do. She tells me so often that she does. I know exactly how to scare her the way she loves. It's just one of those silly little things she often tells me.
She's amazing.
So there we are on the sofa.
She's massaging my leg. And I've completely ignored her. Haven't reacted at all.
I'm playing hard to get.
She knows that. She likes it. She's told me a million times how much that turns her on.
And in turn, it turns me on just as much.
This is why it works between us.
This is why sex solves everything. It always has.
It's the constant.
So, I decide to scare her.
A little surprise.
Just like we've done a thousand times before.
That was the worst decision I've ever made.
I did it because I love her. Because, from the bottom of my heart, I believe it's what she wants. What she needs.
Everything that's happened between us. All those experiences. All those memories. All those feelings over those five years.
I know her.
I love her.
I trust her.
And I trust that she wants me.
So I jump towards her.
The story reaches the same moment: “So I jump towards her.” The hypothetical replay branches here.
The interruption
All of a sudden, everything around us is flashing red.
A piercing alarm fills the room.
I freeze.
What the fuck?
I look at her.
And then I see her face.
Something is wrong.
I stop.
The alarm is part of the imagined story. This page does not play an alarm or flash.
Back to the inventors
What just happened?
We have told the same afternoon twice. In the first telling, the encounter continues and ends in catastrophe. In the second, an alarm interrupts the narrator before penetration.
Our working name for the proposed intervention is the Arch Rape Alarm. It is not a verdict or an accusation. We are asking whether a system could recognise a dangerous misunderstanding early enough to make people stop and establish what each actually wants.
Could it distinguish danger from ordinary intimacy? Would it need intrusive monitoring? Could a false alarm cause harm? We do not yet have those answers. The invention is a hypothesis to be researched, not a proven capability.
No claim is made that a device can detect consent or prevent rape.
Why this matters
He loves her. He believes he knows her. In his mind, they have done the same thing a million times. If it was welcome before, how could this time be different?
That question is the heart of the problem. Familiarity shapes our expectations, but cannot determine another person's wishes on a new occasion.
Readers may sympathise with the narrator or judge him differently. We leave that choice with them. His acceptance of her close friendships is part of the relationship the story portrays. We do not need to instruct readers how to interpret it.
Questions, not conclusions
A different ending,
a different question
Imagine a further variation. A woman says afterwards that she had not expected an intimate encounter, but welcomes it as a lovely surprise. Does her later approval change whether she agreed at the moment it began? Should the law distinguish different circumstances more carefully? Where should culpability, harm, prevention and punishment enter the discussion?
These are questions, not conclusions. Different circumstances can warrant different legal and moral assessments. We should not assume that every event described in a fictional scenario automatically meets the elements of rape.
In England and Wales the relevant law is the Sexual Offences Act 2003. Section 74 requires agreement by choice with freedom and capacity. Section 1 also requires absence of a reasonable belief in consent, taking account of circumstances and steps taken to ascertain it. Consent need not always be spoken aloud, but previous consensual sex and a long relationship do not automatically establish consent on another occasion.
A later expression of approval cannot retroactively create consent that was absent at the time. A person's account of their own experience matters, while the legal classification of an offence is a separate determination.
Read the primary sources below. Legal review of this draft is outstanding.
What we want to learn
Can a system recognise an impending misunderstanding and prevent harm without controlling anyone? What evidence would establish that it works? What privacy and safety safeguards would it need? Could it ever make matters worse? What questions about law and public policy should be openly debated?
We are inviting readers to consider the problem and a possible direction for prevention. We are not asking them to accept a finished answer.
If one person's certainty can be different from another person's wishes, what could help them recognise that difference before harm occurs?
That is the problem we are trying to solve.
An optional exercise
What does the law distinguish?
Explore 100 draft scenarios about consent and the offence of rape in England and Wales. Answer as many or as few as you choose.
This is a preliminary educational draft, not a validated measure of understanding. The repeated scenarios and proposed answer key need legal and editorial review.
Open the questionnaireAnswers stay in this page. No account, submission or tracking.
Sources & publication details
A starting point for further reading
- Sexual Offences Act 2003, section 1 — the offence of rape.
- Sexual Offences Act 2003, section 74 — consent.
- CPS rape and sexual offences guidance — including consent and reasonable belief.
- The Code for Crown Prosecutors — the evidential and public-interest stages.
England and Wales. This working publication is not legal advice. Independent legal review remains outstanding.